The biographies of candidates for the new Supreme Judicial Council include ministerial, deputy-ministerial, parliamentary and other political positions. This has prompted questions about whether members of the executive and legislature should move directly into the body responsible for judicial appointments.
The selection of a new council should draw a clear line against turning the SJC into the next stage of someone’s political career. Work in a government team involves following the policy line of the prime minister and the relevant minister and is based on political trust. A move to the SJC therefore requires convincing guarantees of distance from previous political commitments.
Participation in political cabinets is particularly significant. It involves working directly with a minister, helping implement that minister’s policy and maintaining relationships based on political confidence. Leaving the position, or receiving a later nomination accompanied by a promise of independence, does not erase that part of a person’s professional biography.
Among the candidates is Andrey Yankulov, a former prosecutor and lawyer. From August to November 2014, he was deputy interior minister in the caretaker government of Georgi Bliznashki. From November 2014 until February 22, 2016, he was deputy justice minister in Boyko Borissov’s second government—initially under Hristo Ivanov and later, for a period, under Ekaterina Zaharieva. In 2026, Yankulov served as caretaker deputy prime minister and justice minister under Andrey Gyurov.
Emil Dechev is a judge who was appointed deputy justice minister on January 27, 2022, under Prime Minister Kiril Petkov and Justice Minister Nadezhda Yordanova. He remained in the position in both caretaker governments led by Galab Donev, under Minister Krum Zarkov, and later under Prime Minister Nikolay Denkov, in Atanas Slavov’s team, until April 2024. In 2026, Dechev served as caretaker interior minister under Andrey Gyurov.
Tanya Radulovska-Madamzhieva, a lawyer and former judge, was deputy justice minister in Andrey Gyurov’s caretaker government in 2026, working in Andrey Yankulov’s team. Her participation in the executive branch is therefore very recent.
Vasil Pandov is a lawyer and university lecturer, as well as a former member of parliament from We Continue the Change. In 2022, he headed the political cabinet of Health Minister Asena Serbezova in Kiril Petkov’s government. His political record includes both leading a ministerial political cabinet and serving parliamentary terms.
Veselin Vuchkov is a professor of criminal procedure. From 2009 to 2013, he was deputy interior minister in Boyko Borissov’s first government under Minister Tsvetan Tsvetanov. He later served as a GERB member of parliament in the 42nd and 43rd National Assemblies, and from November 7, 2014, to March 11, 2015, he was interior minister in Borissov’s second government. His political positions are further in the past, a distinction that should also be taken into account.
Five of the seven candidates supported by We Continue the Change lawmakers have direct experience in the executive or legislative branches. Democratic Bulgaria lawmakers support three of the same candidates—Yankulov, Dechev and Radulovska-Madamzhieva—who took part in caretaker government in 2026.
Tsveta Rangelova, supported by a lawmaker from Revival, also has a direct party and parliamentary background as a former member of parliament from that formation. The requirement for distance from political power should apply to her as well.
The debate also includes the secondment of magistrates. Vasil Pandov has raised the risk of dependency created by this mechanism and proposed restrictions. The same scrutiny of appointment procedures and the trust placed in an appointee should also be applied when assessing his own work in a political cabinet.
Long-term secondments should be addressed through clear criteria and concrete decisions. Candidates with repeated ministerial and deputy-ministerial appointments must likewise explain what guarantees they offer that the political trust on which their government careers were built will not become an expectation of loyalty within the SJC.
The parliamentary quota is not a party quota. Lawmakers’ right to nominate and elect SJC members does not give them a right to exert influence over those members afterward. Proximity to a party leadership, parliamentary group or influential lawmakers cannot replace evidence of independence. The council must not contain reserved places for the governing party, the opposition or self-described reformers.
Closeness to one party cannot be treated as grounds for distrust while closeness to another is presented as a guarantee of reform. The proposals of Progressive Bulgaria include judges, lawyers, academics and university lecturers with careers in justice and legal scholarship. Professional records, integrity and concrete solutions to the system’s problems should guide the selection, with the same strict review applied to every candidate.
The justice system needs difficult reforms, functioning competitions, timely evaluations and fair personnel decisions. If the SJC becomes an extension of political cabinets and parliamentary confrontations, those tasks may again give way to party deals, personal ambitions and political or public-relations campaigns.
The body responsible for judicial appointments must not be a refuge after a political mandate or a springboard to another position. To protect justice, it must be convincingly independent from those who elected it.
Source: dariknews.bg
|